March Pizza Madness 2026 - And the winner is…

WE HAVE A NEW CHAMPION! 🍕🏆

The votes have been tallied, the final buzzer has sounded, and the results are official. After a record-breaking tournament that saw over 2,000 votes in the final round alone, we have a new titleholder in the Garden State!

Congratulations to PIZZA CITY of Woodland Park!

In an incredible showdown, the hungry newcomer has done the unthinkable—dethroning a 90-year-old powerhouse and two-time champion to claim the 2026 March Pizza Madness Crown. From a last-minute wild card rally to the top of the podium, Pizza City proved that every single vote counts.

To our Runner-Up, Patsy’s Tavern: Thank you for being a legendary part of this tournament. You reminded us all why New Jersey pizza is in a league of its own.

To the Fans: Thank you for making 2026 our biggest year yet! You showed up for your local shops, argued over toppings, and proved that pizza is the true heart of our community.

Now, there’s only one thing left to do... Go grab a celebratory slice at Pizza City!

Buon appetito!

Follow the Towncast on Instagram and Facebook to keep an eye on the action.